Home › Electric Vehicles › Tesla Autopilot and FSD linked to three more fatal US crashes in NHTSA filings
Electric Vehicles

Tesla Autopilot and FSD linked to three more fatal US crashes in NHTSA filings

calendar_today
schedule 3 min read
Tesla Autopilot or FSD engaged in three more fatal crashes, NHTSA filings show

Summary

An investigation matching local reports with Tesla's filings to NHTSA identified three additional fatal US crashes in which Autopilot or Full Self-Driving was engaged. The findings raise questions about transparency, as Tesla redacts details in its federal crash reports as confidential business information.

Three fatal crashes involving Tesla vehicles in the United States have been identified in federal reporting as cases where Autopilot or “Full Self-Driving” (FSD) was engaged, adding to a series of fatal incidents involving Tesla driver-assistance systems.

The crashes were identified by Fred Lambert at Electrek, who is matching local crash reports with records Tesla submitted to the US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA).

Under the agency’s reporting order, manufacturers must report certain crashes if a Level 2 driver-assistance system was engaged within 30 seconds of the crash and the incident meets specified criteria, including a fatality, airbag deployment or hospital transport. The reports do not by themselves establish that the system caused a crash.

As of November 16, Lambert had identified 12 crashes in his investigation that together claimed 16 lives, including drivers, passengers, a man who stopped to help at a crash scene and a motorcyclist.

The investigation has been complicated by Tesla redacting information in its NHTSA filings, citing “confidential business information”.

NHTSA says its public incident data excludes information claimed as confidential business information, as well as personal information. Lambert says Tesla is the only high-volume reporter to withhold all the details he is seeking.

Three more crashes were identified and reported on Monday. In one, a Tesla Model X veered off the Golden Gate Parkway in Naples, Florida, hit a traffic signal pole and overturned, killing a 50-year-old passenger.

In another, a Tesla Model 3 drove into an overturned truck on Interstate 75 near Naples, killing two passengers and a man who had stopped to help.

A third crash saw a Tesla Model Y leave a parkway in El Dorado Hills, California, hit a tree and catch fire, killing three of the four people inside. In each case, Tesla’s report to NHTSA said Autopilot or FSD was engaged.

Local media reported the crashes but did not mention that a driver-assistance system had been engaged, according to Electrek.

NHTSA’s public data also records more Level 2 ADAS crashes involving Tesla vehicles than any other manufacturer, but it’s worth nothing those figures are raw report counts, rather than crash rates adjusted for the number of vehicles equipped with each system or the distance they travel. NHTSA also notes limitations in the completeness and quality of the data.

The number of reported Tesla crashes is not, on its own, proof that Autopilot or FSD caused them. But the newly identified cases raise questions about how much the public can learn about crashes involving these systems when key details in the federal reports are withheld.

Share this article

The Green Wire Weekly

Weekly deep dive into sustainable transport.

Comments

No approved comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave A Reply

Comments are temporarily unavailable.

Related Coverage